• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to header navigation
  • Skip to footer navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Display Search Bar
  • About
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
Follow 5 Minutes For Mom on Facebook Follow 5 Minutes For Mom on Twitter Follow 5 Minutes For Mom on Pinterest Follow 5 Minutes For Mom on Instagram Follow 5 Minutes For Mom on YouTube Follow 5 Minutes For Mom via RSS

5 Minutes for Mom

Main navigation

  • Home
  • Recipes
    • Course
      • Breakfast and Brunch
      • Snack
      • Lunch
      • Appetizer
      • Dinner
      • Dessert
    • Ingredient
      • Apple
      • Beef
      • Blueberry
      • Chicken
      • Chocolate
      • Cranberry
      • Peach
      • Pumpkin
      • Squash
      • Strawberry
      • Tomato
      • Vegetables
      • Zucchini
    • Method
      • Air Fryer
      • Baking
      • Grilling
      • Instant Pot
      • No Bake
      • One Dish
      • Slow Cooker
    • Type
      • Breads and Rolls
      • Cakes and Muffins
      • Condiments
      • Cookies and Bars
      • Drinks
      • Food for Kids
      • Gluten-Free
      • Main Dish
      • Pies and Crisps
      • Salads
      • Sandwiches and Wraps
      • Side Dishes
      • Smoothies
      • Soup
  • Crafts & DIY
    • Crafts
    • DIY
    • Kids Crafts
    • Printables
    • Scrapbooking
    • Sewing
  • Family Life
    • Giveaways
    • Lifestyle
    • Marriage
    • Motherhood
    • Parenting
    • Pet Care
    • Special Needs
    • Time Management
    • Travel
  • Holidays
    • New Year’s
    • Valentine’s Day
    • St. Patrick’s Day
    • Easter
    • Mother’s Day
    • Fourth of July
    • Halloween
    • Thanksgiving
    • Christmas

When It’s Too Hard to Say Goodbye: Recreating Characters in Fiction

August 15, 2016 by Elizabeth

This post may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy here.

ShareTweetPinPocketMail

5 Minutes for Books reviewer Elizabeth loves the classics. Here are her thoughts on some of the interpretations by newer authors.

Avid readers can come to feel that characters on the page are real-life friends, especially when a beloved character is featured in a series of books. So when the character’s creator dies, the temptation to find another good author to recreate the series of books is irresistible. All good things must come to an end, the saying goes, but why? What if they didn’t have to end? Why not figure out a way to keep them going? It is this way of thinking that is responsible for many movies and for all those sequels and re-creations of classics in novel form.

New Authors Classics

So far, so good. But then the question arises…is it even possible? Lately, acclaimed author Sophie Hannah, excellent writer of very creepy domestic thrillers, has turned her hand to recreating Agatha Christie’s beloved Hercule Poirot, the Belgium detective with enormous mustaches and an egg-shaped head who was famous for sitting and thinking and solving mysteries through psychology and use of the “little grey cells.” In recent years we have also seen Jill Paton Walsh, herself a mystery writer, taking on Dorothy Sayers’ beloved Lord Peter and Lady Harriet Wimsey. And many people have tried to keep Sherlock Holmes going.

I will admit my own bias up front. I think this rarely if ever works. Oh I understand the whys and hows of it all. How I wish there were more Dorothy Sayers’ novels; how I wish Agatha Christie were actually immortal and were still producing new books that reflected our own times. However, in general, no matter how vivid the author’s own creations are, when she is forced to recreate someone else’s character–especially a character beloved by millions–it is difficult or even impossible to make that character more than a pale cardboard cutout of a its former self. Let’s look at what works and what doesn’t.

closed casketAgatha Christie by Sophie Hannah:

Hannah has now written two Hercule Poirot novels: Monogram Murders (linked to my review at 5 Minutes for Books) and Closed Casket.  In both, she has created an interesting plot, a puzzle worthy of Dame Agatha herself. In both, Poirot is little more than a collection of ticks and mannerisms. However, she has created a new sidekick, a policeman named Edward Catchpool, and by focusing the action on him and his thoughts, and keeping Poirot sort of off to one side, she manages to make it work. She’s forced to set the books in the late 20s/early 30s, and that requires a different skill set. I am just finishing Closed Casket and I think it’s definitely the better of the two books. I have hopes that this new Poirot/Catchpool series will only get better.

thrones dominationsDorothy Sayers by Jill Paton Walsh:

I actually first heard of Walsh when she was hired by the Sayers estate to finish a book that Sayers had started and left copious notes for: Thrones, Dominations. And it’s excellent! All of Sayers’ great characters with a bit more modernity, a bit more of the characters’ psychology and thoughts. I loved it. It’s really good, a near-perfect collaboration between two authors. I then went and read some of Walsh’s own works and enjoyed them as well. She’s not on the level of Sayers but that’s okay–so few people are, after all. But I have been very disappointed with her following works recreating the Wimsey characters: A Presumption of Death and The Attenbury Emeralds. Peter and Harriet just don’t feel right. I realize that is very subjective, but if you can’t get the voice right, you haven’t succeeded at recreating the character.

laurie king mary russellArthur Conan Doyle by various authors:

Many different authors have tried their hand at recreating the iconic Sherlock Holmes and his sidekick, Dr. Watson. I knew of a couple, but a quick Amazon search showed up many, many more.  There are various degrees of success; for example I have enjoyed a couple of Laurie R. King’s series of Holmes and his marriage to Mary Russell. However, the best reinterpretation by a long shot is the BBC television series starring Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman. Why? Because it’s probably the farthest removed from the original, and so it becomes more of an homage, less of a slavish copy. The freedom that comes with the new territory allows imagination and creativity to flourish. I read Arthur Conan Doyle’s originals in high school and hadn’t read them since, but rereading them after watching the modern version was a fun exercise in tracing sources and recognizing new versions of old stories.

widesargassoThe common denominator is that, oddly enough, the farther you go from the original, the better. If you try to stay too close, it doesn’t work. I’ve read two recreations of Jane Eyre that both worked remarkably well. One, The Flight of Gemma Hardy, is an homage, a modern retelling that does a good job picturing our equivalents to Victorian people. The other, Wide Sargasso Sea, tells the story from the point of view of Bertha, Rochester’s first wife, the madwoman in the attic. Both had enough original material that each story stands on its own, which I think is another important element, and both weren’t trying to hard to recreate a beloved character in a new role.

What about you? Do you have any homages, spin-offs, or recreations that you think work particularly well? Perhaps you think I’m ridiculously fussy (you would not be the only one) and that all these new versions are fantastic. Let me know in comments, please!

ShareTweetPinPocketMail
Acer Chromebook R 11 – Perfect for Back to School
How To Get Your Kids Excited About Real Food

About Elizabeth

Elizabeth is a voracious reader with eclectic tastes who loves being part of the team at 5 Minutes for Books. She's lived in 7 countries and is currently in Oregon, where she spends most of her time with Iraqi refugees. She has 3 teens.

Reader Interactions


Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Bringing Moms Together

We are Janice and Susan, twin bloggers and work-at-home moms. We're here to inspire, encourage & empower you.

Meet Us…

Work With Us…

Subscribe via Email

to be first to read new posts

Trending Now

Valentine Pretzels – How to Make Chocolate Covered Pretzels

Valentine Pretzels – How to Make Chocolate Covered Pretzels

Raspberry Coulis – How To Make Raspberry Sauce

Raspberry Coulis – How To Make Raspberry Sauce

Among Us Costumes – How To Make Pretty DIY Among Us Cosplay Outfits

Among Us Costumes – How To Make Pretty DIY Among Us Cosplay Outfits

Oven Roasted Potatoes and Peppers Recipe

Oven Roasted Potatoes and Peppers Recipe

browse around

  • Posts by Susan
  • Posts by Janice
  • Favorite Recipes
  • Favorite Crafts
  • Giveaways
  • All Posts

Footer

Recipes

Valentine Pretzels – How to Make Chocolate Covered Pretzels

Valentine Pretzels – How to Make Chocolate Covered Pretzels

Good Morning Breakfast Smoothie Recipes

Good Morning Breakfast Smoothie Recipes

Raspberry Coulis – How To Make Raspberry Sauce

Raspberry Coulis – How To Make Raspberry Sauce

Crafts/DIY

Valentine’s Day Crafts For Kids – Super Cute and Easy Valentine Craft Ideas

Valentine’s Day Crafts For Kids – Super Cute and Easy Valentine Craft Ideas

Animal Ears – How to Make an Easy No Sew Animal Ears Headband

Animal Ears – How to Make an Easy No Sew Animal Ears Headband

Free Halloween Printables For Kids

Free Halloween Printables For Kids

Giveaways

Valentine’s Day Gifts For Mom

Valentine’s Day Gifts For Mom

School Supplies List and Back to School Shopping Guide

School Supplies List and Back to School Shopping Guide

REDEEMING LOVE Set to Strike Gold on the Big Screen #RedeemingLoveMovie

REDEEMING LOVE Set to Strike Gold on the Big Screen #RedeemingLoveMovie

Follow 5 Minutes For Mom on Facebook Follow 5 Minutes For Mom on Twitter Follow 5 Minutes For Mom on Pinterest Follow 5 Minutes For Mom on Instagram Follow 5 Minutes For Mom on YouTube Follow 5 Minutes For Mom via RSS
  • About
  • Contact
  • Work with Us
  • Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2023 5 Minutes for MomTheme by Melissa Rose Design and Once Coupled